This paper reconsiders celibacy not as a mere absence of sexual activity but as a substantive ethical and existential stance with a long history in Buddhist, Christian, and classical philosophical traditions. Drawing on antinatalist ethics, Epicurean hedonology, and Schopenhauerian pessimism, I argue that the conventional justification of sexual activity as a societal necessity — grounded in concerns about reproduction and demographic continuity — conflates descriptive biological function with normative ethical value. Once this conflation is set aside, I argue, the ethical evaluation of one's mode of living can be grounded instead in individual autonomy and self-sustaining quality of life (QOL) rather than reproductive obligation. Engaging with David Benatar's asymmetry argument, I suggest that the moral status of humanity's demographic continuity need not be treated as self-evidently overriding individual self-determination. I then draw on Epicurus's distinction between stable and transient pleasure, and on Schopenhauer's account of sexual desire as an expression of a species-oriented will-to-live, to argue that celibacy can constitute a coherent discipline of autonomous, self-sustained flourishing. Finally, I consider four objections — from relational psychology, from the alleged self-undermining character of universalized antinatalism, from the charge of theological parochialism, and from the subjectivity of QOL judgments — and offer replies. I conclude that celibacy, properly understood, merits recognition as one exemplary and defensible path of ethical self-cultivation, rather than as a deficiency to be explained away.
要旨は Takuya Nemoto によるものです。DOI のメタデータに要旨がないため、著者が投稿の issue で示しました。書式のない文にしたほかは手を加えず、CC BY 4.0 のもとで載せています。著者の言語のままで、訳は付けていません。
書架記号は書架の上の札で、識別子ではありません。この記録は、Sophaxis の番号(Sophaxis:2026.0004)と DOI で引きます。
引用
引用の書式は英語のままです。
APA
Nemoto, T. (2026). The Nobility and Exemplarity of the Celibate Individual: An Antinatalist and Ascetic Reconsideration of Autonomy and Quality of Life [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22058254
Chicago(著者・年)
Nemoto, Takuya. 2026. “The Nobility and Exemplarity of the Celibate Individual: An Antinatalist and Ascetic Reconsideration of Autonomy and Quality of Life.” Preprint, Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22058254.
BibTeX
@misc{nemoto2026sophaxis20260004,
author = {Takuya Nemoto},
title = {The Nobility and Exemplarity of the Celibate Individual: An Antinatalist and Ascetic Reconsideration of Autonomy and Quality of Life},
year = {2026},
howpublished = {Zenodo},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.22058254},
note = {Preprint, not peer-reviewed. Listed on Sophaxis as 2026.0004}
}
程度(著者の申告):Drafting: a generative model drafted text, proofs, code or figures that the authors revised(生成モデルが文・証明・コード・図の下書きを作り、著者が手を入れた)
This revised version of the manuscript was prepared with the assistance of Claude (Claude Sonnet 5), a large language model AI system developed by Anthropic, PBC, in August 2026. AI assistance was used to: (i) restructure the argument into discrete, numbered sections; (ii) situate the paper's claims within existing philosophical literature, including Buddhist, Christian, Epicurean, Schopenhauerian, and Kantian sources; (iii) draft an objections-and-replies section addressing relational, self-undermining, parochialism, and subjectivity objections to the paper's central argument; and (iv) expand and copyedit the prose of the original manuscript. The author reviewed, revised, and takes full intellectual responsibility for all claims, arguments, and citations herein. AI assistance was not used to generate original empirical data, and this paper makes no empirical claims beyond what is explicitly cited. The AI system does not qualify as an author of this work; this disclosure is provided in the interest of transparency regarding the drafting process.
注記と訂正
2026-11-02The author's errata for the three philosophy papers (https://github.com/cpsbvbng26-dotcom/autonomy-and-self-cultivation/blob/main/ERRATA.md) record that the statement on language models leaves out two things: the manuscript was written in Japanese and the published English text is a translation by a language model, and the tools used for the translation are not named (E5).